Bootability test for SLICK807 686 and AMD64 variants 20230723 GLF ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Backstory of The Problem: ------------------------- GLF has built remix OSes using the Debian-supported "live-build" system for over 10 years. These rewmixes are all live bootable and include a matching installer, and each contains a custom preinstalled and runnable set of applications and programming libraries which provide general computing functionality and support for various personal and professional interests of GLF. One big reason GLF has adopted Debian Mate as the foundation for custom remix builds is that Debian continues to support 32-bit versions of its OS, with fairly complete repositories which almost completely mirror the available software for 64-bit alternatives. Though most other Linux OS vendors appear to have abandoned 32-bit support, with Debian older computers with CPUs such as Pentium 4 and Intel Atom can still run a functional modern operating systems, extending their service lives into a second decade. Historically, GLF has built, tested, and installed these local remixes on both 32-bit computers (i386 arch) and 64-bit Intel and/or AMD 64-bit computers (amd64 arch). Boot instances of 32-bit OS images have always been used to build 32-bit OS remixes, and 64-bit OS images have always been used to build 64-bit OS remixes. However, since 64 bit (amd64 or x86_64) software and OSes can run on 64-bit capable CPUs, it has been GLF practice to build ALL such remixes on the newer, faster 64-bit computers available to GLF. Until Debian 12 was released this was largely transparent, since on 64-bit computers the 32-bit and 64-bit OS user exeperiences were almost identical except where word bit size was important, such as in executable format, differences in source code, and program size. In fact, prior to Debian 12, the main notable difference between 32-bit and 64-bt variants of a given remix was that the 64-bit ISOs were bootable under Secure Boot, but the 32-bit were not. For some time, it appeared Debian would address this gap, but alas, they did/could not. This is not a large problem, in that most computers of the i686 era are not affected by Secure Boot in the BIOS. Though UEFI/Secure Boot is built around a 32-bit executable, it seems to be present only within the domain of systems with 64-bit processors, especially to run Microsoft Windows 8 and later OS. Besides, secure Boot is optional, and many (including GLF) choose not to configure their computers to use it, instead using either UEFI or Legacy Boot without Secure Boot enabled. Doing so generally makes it easier to explore alternative live boot OSes, backup/recovery software, etc. Debian issues a major upgrade of its OS about every 2 years. On June 10, 2023, Debian officially released Debian 12 (bookworm) which supplants Debian 12 (bullseye) as its "current stable" OS. Early OS builds of Debian 12 based live boot remixed Linux OS showed concerning boot issues when run on on certain computers, which called into question whether Debian support for 32-bit 686 alternatives was ready to release 686 versions to casual users. Debian 12 686 (i386 arch) builds began to show a problem on ONLY SOME computers, where the boot to GUI failed somewhere before the desktop UI could appear. Presumably, this problem relates to startup of X.org window handlers or upgraded video drivers between Debian 11 and Debian 12. Unfortunately, most of the GLF experience attempting to build and run 686 systems was limited to a pair of personal computers, both Dell PCs, one an Inspirion desktop and the other a Latitude laptop. On the Dell desktop, a normal 686-based OS live boot would die somewhere on a black screen, without ever showing the mouse cursor or UI. However, if the same live boot was edited to include the "nomodeset" parameter (which prevents loading the accelerated video driver) the boot proceeds normally, but video resolution is typicaly reduced and not changeable by menu. It is possible to build new 686 systems as expected using this "hobbled" boot, though some programs take longer to run given the lack of video acceleration. Unfortunately, the Dell laptop situation was worse. Not only did a normal boot exhibit the stalled boot symptom, if the "nomodeset" alternative was booted, though it allowed an initial boot environmentt, if the user attempted to logout, the screen wold go gray and the computer would hang, unable to log back in. This was particularly troublesome because GLF live boot OSes start up with a "nag screen" urging the user to change passwords, after which the UI is automatically logged out to allow the password change to take effect. On the Dell laptop, this became impossible. After 2 months of building remixes, trying "fixes", and testing, GLF found no improvement for the boot problem for all 686-based builds. The workaround was to push "nomodeset" into the default boot parameters for the 686 variants so that the default boot would at least run to completion and lallow other use and testing. This was not ideal, but kept development going. GLF had been ready to write off the possibility of fully functional 32-bit Debian OS builds, but decided to perform a personal testing survey to establish the problem's prevalence and symptoms on as many different computer types as GLF could personally round up. Because GLF is something of a pack rat but not wealthy, most of the computers available to GLF are "vintage", not very new or "state of art". GLF eventually tested 13 computers of widely varying age. The results are tabulated below. Test results: ------------- Each computer was booted with SLICK807_686 (32-bit) and SLICK807_AMD64 (64-bit) and run through several tests using the built-in System Monitor and CPU-X utilities, and noting video characteristics under a variety of load situations including use of web browsers. It turns out the situation is not as bad for the 686 builds as previously thought, though some users may have different experiences. RAM/"HD" Computer tested BIOS date CPU Type #Threads Gb avail ------------------------------- --------- --------------------------------------------- -------- ----------- Acer Aspire One V1029 netbook 2010 32 bit Intel Atom N270 (Diamondville) 2 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 (945 GME) 1024x600 1.0 of 2.0 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe 800x600 AMD64 Boot Normal: N/A Dell Latitude E6430 laptop 2015 64 bit Intel i5-3340M (Ivy Bridge) 4 686 Boot Normal: FAIL (black screen, no X) 686 Boot nomodeset: logout FAIL Video: i915 llvmpipe 1600x900 1.0 of 2.0 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 Mesa intel HD Graphics 4000 (IVBGT2) 1600x900 1.8 of 4.0 Dell Inspirion 3650 2016 64 bit Intel Core i3-6100 (Skylake) 4 686 Boot Normal: FAIL 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe 1920x1080 1.0 of 2.0 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 Mesa HD Grahics 530 (SKLGT2) 1920x1080 2.9 of 5.7 Acer Aspire EA50 laptop 2013 64 bit Intel Pentium B960 (Sandy Bridge) 2 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 Intel HD Graphics 2000 (SNBGT1) 1366x768 1.3 of 2.5 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe 1366x768 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 Mesa Intel HD Graphics 2000 (SNBGT1) 1366x768 1.9 if 3.6 Dell Optiplex 7010 desktop 2013 64 bit Intel Core i5-3470 (Ivy Bridge) 4 686 Boot Normal: FAIL 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe Intel Xeon E3-1200 v2 1280x1024 1.8 of 3.4 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video i915 Mesa Intel HD 2500 (IVBGT1) 1280x1024 3.8 of 7.5 Gateway MT6841 laptop 2007 32 bit Intel Core i3-6100 (Skylake) 4 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 (945GM/GMS/GME) 1280x800 1.0 of 2.0 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe 1024x768 AMD64 Boot Normal: N/A Acer Aspire 5000 laptop 2006 64 bit AMD Turion 64 ML-32 (Lancaster) 1 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: llvmpipe SiS 661/741/760 PCI/AGP, 662/61Gx PCIE 1024x768 1.0 of 1.9 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: llvmpipe 1024x768 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: no driver 1024x768 1.0 of 1.9 eMachines EL1200-05w desktop 2008 64 bit AMD Athlon 64 2650e 1 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: (nouveau) NV4C C61 GeForce 6150SE nForce 430 1680x1050 0.9 of 1.7 (nouveau video driver seems more stable than in prior versions of Debian -- never stalled, screen never tore) 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: llvmpipe 1024x768 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: (nouveau) NV4C C61 GeForce 6150SE nForce 430 1680x1080 0.9 of 1.7 (nouveau video driver seems more stable than in prior versions of Debian -- never stalled, screen never tore) eMachines EL1352G-01w desktop 2010 64 bit AMD Sempron 145 (Sargas) 1 686 Boot Normal: OK Video:(nouveau) NV4C C61 GeForce 6150SE nForce 430 1680x1050 1.9 of 3.6 (nouveau video driver seems more stable than in prior versions of Debian -- never stalled, screen never tore) 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video:llvmpipe 1024x768 1.7 of 3.2 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video:(nouveau) NV4C C61 GeForce 6150SE nForce 430 1680x1080 4.1 of 7.6 (nouveau video driver seems more stable than in prior versions of Debian -- never stalled, screen never tore) HP ??? desktop 2011 64 bit Intel Core 2 Duo E7500 (Wolfdale) 2 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: Intel 4 Series Integrated Graphics 1280x1024 1.8 of 3.4 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: llvmpipe 1366x768 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 Mesa Intel B43 (ELK) 2.0 of 3.8 ??? HUANANZHI X58 desktop 2018 64 bit Intel Xeon X5650 (Gulftown) 12 686 Boot Normal: FAIL (black screen with mouse pointer, no X) 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: llvmpipe 1920x1080 1.6 of 3.1 AMD64 Boot Normal: OK Video: NV134 GP104 GeForce GTX1080 1920x1080 8.3 of 15.6 IBM Thinkpad laptop 2002 32 bit Mobile Intel Pentium 4-M 1 (unable to boot with USB, difficult to boot DVD, able to live boot by imaging ISO to hard drive) 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: AMD RV100/M6 Rage/Radeon Mobility (Radeon) 1024x768 0.5 of 1.0 (X.org under Radeon driver unstable -- random window moves or clicks locked or blanked screen) 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: llvmpipe 1024x768 0.5 of 1.0 AMD64 Boot Normal: N/A Dell Inspirion 2200 laptop 2005 32 bit Intel Pentium M (Dothan) 1 686 Boot Normal: OK Video: i915 915GM/GMS/910GML Express 1024x768 0.6 of 1.2 (tested 686 live boot installation on this machine -- worked OK) 686 Boot nomodeset: OK Video: i915 llvmpipe 1024x768 0.6 of 1.2 AMD64 Boot Normal: N/A (NOTE: Chromium would not run due to lack of SSE3 support by CPU -- has MMX and SSE 1&2, not SSE3) Conclusions: ------------ Several important observations from the above tests: 1) If a machine supports 32 bits ONLY, either the nomodeset or the normal (GPU driver) boot of the 686 image will work. 2) Many of the machines which support 64 bits will successfully boot the 686 image in either nomodeset or normal (driver) mode, mostly machines which are older than 2012. However, some newer 64 bit machines will fail booting the 686 normally, but will boot if nomodeset is specified. 3) All of the machines with 64 bit support booted the amd64 (64-bit) image and ran successfully. 4) The two machines with Nvidia video cards ran well with the nouveau driver. The driver appears to be more stable than previously experienced in earlier versions of Debian and appears fully useable. Because of the above tests, it appears that the 686 boot is ready for most users to use normally, without nomodeset. GLF plans to restore the 686 "legacy" boot configuration to assume normal boot with detected driver. If a user experiences problems, he can either select "basic Video" form the legacy boot menu, or in the UEFI boot menu, can edit the boot parameters ('e', edit, F10 to proceed with changes). Tis is the way GLF set up the live boot menu before the "unbootable" 686 video problems showed up (on a few machines).